Trends

Debates, discussions, news articles, cultural differences stories and everyday life blah blah.

On The Road

Follow me in China, in Central and in South America, in Australia, in South-East Asia or in Europe. Enjoy the pics and crazy travel stories!

Immigration

How to immigrate to Canada, how to apply for Canadian citizenship, and how to tackle the challenges newcomers face.

Baby Mark Floyd

Mark, our Canadian-Chinese-French baby, was born in Ottawa on October 12, 2012. These are our adventures as parents-in-training.

The Saturday Series

The ten post Saturday series: how to immigrate to Canada, how to find a job, interviews with immigrants… and more!

Home » Immigration

I Belong Here... And There Too

Written by on July 8, 2009 – 10:24 pm20 Comments | 2,256 Read this
Canada Cookies

Canada Cook­ies

Five days after the big cer­e­mony, I still have to pinch myself from time to time. I. Am. Cana­dian. God, I love it.

A lot of peo­ple around me are quite curi­ous about it. Can I get dual cit­i­zen­ship? Yes I can, I didn’t lose my French cit­i­zen­ship. How long did the whole process take? The cit­i­zen­ship process took 11 months, but I had been in Canada for almost five years before that. Do I feel dif­fer­ent? Well, yes and no. I feel like I achieved some­thing. I am what I am, a bit of this and a bit of that I guess.

This got me think­ing. I was born in France, of French par­ents, so I am French. No-brainer here. But because I left the coun­try right after grad­u­at­ing from high school, lit­tle by lit­tle, I lost my French iden­tity. Obvi­ously, I adapted to Canada — this was bound to hap­pen. But I also lost it in a very prac­ti­cal way. For exam­ple, as a French, I was cov­ered by the French health care sys­tem and had a health card (carte de sécu). Well, because I stopped liv­ing there, it’s not valid any­more. I’m not sure what the require­ments are to keep your health cov­er­age in France but my card stopped work­ing some­times in 2006.

I used to vote in France. Well, basi­cally, I would go to the French embassy in Ottawa and fill up the papers to give my father my proxy. I believe that vot­ing is both a right and a respon­si­bil­ity and I was happy to do it. I vote for the pres­i­den­tial elec­tions. I vote for some­thing else, can’t remem­ber what. And then next thing you know, it was the munic­i­pal elec­tions, and then the Euro­pean ref­er­en­dum on the Con­sti­tu­tion, and then the regional elec­tions… and then I got lost. I didn’t know the can­di­dates, didn’t live any­where in France and frankly, I couldn’t have cared less who was win­ning. I just didn’t have an opin­ion because. I had lost the taste for French politics.

I slowly started to remove all my French IDs left in my wal­let to make some room for the Cana­dian ones. A carte de sécu for an Ontario Health Card, a carte d’identité for a per­ma­nent res­i­dent card, a carte d’électeur for a library card…

Even­tu­ally, all of my IDs expired and I didn’t renew them. Deal­ing with the French con­sulate in Toronto (since the embassy in Ottawa is now basi­cally use­less) was too much has­sle. I was left with only one piece of valid ID– inci­den­tally the most impor­tant one: my French pass­port, issued in 2003, and valid for 10 years.

Mean­while, I had obtained all my Cana­dian IDs as I had many rights as a per­ma­nent res­i­dent: full access to the job mar­ket, social ben­e­fits and health care. The only things I couldn’t do were vot­ing and apply­ing for a Cana­dian passport.

I loved the irony. I had no sta­tus in France but I had a French pass­port, and my life was in Canada but I couldn’t vote nor have a passport.

It became less funny when, last year, the French admin­is­tra­tion sud­denly remem­bered I existed. My par­ents received a let­ter for me: I was called for jury duty. But not just any jury duty: a sev­eral month-long mur­der trial jury duty.

Shit, or rather, merde. What the…?

Well, because I never really “moved” to Canada, I never informed the French admin­is­tra­tion that I had left the coun­try. It’s a bit of a grey area here. If you move later in life, when you have a job, prop­erty etc. obvi­ously you have to deal with taxes, clos­ing bank accounts etc. But in my case, I went to work to Hong Kong right after I grad­u­ated from high school and attended uni­ver­sity in France while I was trav­el­ing and while later I was in Canada (and yes, I grad­u­ated in case you are won­der­ing). That’s it. I have never really worked in France (except for a few very tem­po­rary posi­tions) so I didn’t have to pay taxes. I have never rented a place, my offi­cial address is still at my par­ents’. I had no belong­ing, no prop­er­ties so I didn’t move offi­cially. I sim­ply started spend­ing more and more time abroad till the day I became a per­ma­nent res­i­dent in Canada.

So appar­ently, I had no rights to health care, ben­e­fits etc. in France (sounds logic) but I could be called for jury duty. Weird.

I sent a let­ter explain­ing that I was now liv­ing in Canada, work­ing, and that I wouldn’t be able to attend a sev­eral month-long trial. I do take my duties seri­ously, but I would have had a hard time com­plet­ing this one.

It wasn’t a prob­lem since I never heard from them after that. But it got me think­ing. What did hav­ing French cit­i­zen­ship mean to me? And how about Cana­dian citizenship?

I’m glad I became Cana­dian. I chose this coun­try as my new home and I plan to ful­fill my duties as a cit­i­zen. I don’t mind being French either and I will always be Euro­pean, at least to a cer­tain extent. But I don’t care about Bastille Day, I can’t sing La Mar­seil­laise, I don’t vote any­more… I don’t even speak French on a reg­u­lar basis…! I’m cer­tainly not using my rights as a French cit­i­zen (although I do com­plain from time to time) nor ful­fill­ing my duties. Weird.

How about you guys? Expats, immi­grants, new­com­ers, new cit­i­zens? How do you deal with hav­ing dual cit­i­zen­ship, or liv­ing abroad? Do you still vote back home, cel­e­brate hol­i­days etc.?

Tagged with:

20 Comments »

  • RennyBA says:

    It has been so very inter­est­ing to fol­low your process to a fully suc­cess. I do under­stand you are happy, proud and relieved.

    It has never been a ques­tion for me, but of course my Amer­i­can wife who came live with me in Nor­way have thought about it. I don’t think US accept dual cit­i­zen­ship though. It’s an impor­tant step, so of course I leave it up to her and sup­port her what­ever she choose.

  • DianeCA says:

    Renny is right, he beat me to the responce. I can’t have dual cit­i­zen­ship so although I can apply for Nor­we­gian cit­i­zen­ship now I have not done so yet. It’s hard to make that deci­sion when you have to let go of your home coun­try. I am very happy for you though, and its great that you can ‘belong’ both places.

  • Zhu says:

    @tikno — It’s true: I made bureau­crats’ lives eas­ier! :lol: Thanks for vis­it­ing and tak­ing the time to comment!

    @Em — Hi Em, thanks for your mes­sage! Ire­land must be a bau­ti­ful place. I must admit I’m not a huge fan of the UK (except for Lon­don) but I would love to visit Ire­land. Unfor­tu­nately, I keep on fly­ing over it when going to France, but that’s it! Oh, well, I can still read Mar­ian Keyes’ books…

    I can imag­ine that, in term of iden­tity, it’s even more weird to move from one UE coun­try to another, due to the lack of paper­work. Yet I guess after 10 years, you are turn­ing more and more Irish… and less French!

    How come you chose a Cana­dian author for your studies?

    @Soleil — The cook­ies are actu­ally… Obama’s cook­ies! :lol:

    Let me explain. Obama vis­ited Ottawa some­times in Feb­ru­ary (I wasn’t there, we were in Brazil) and stopped at the local French bak­ery, right besides the Par­lia­ment. Pic­tures were taken etc. and he appar­ently ate one of these cook­ies. The bak­eries has called it the “Obama cook­ies” and dis­play them along numer­ous pictures.

    @Final_Transit — I don’t know if I would have been will­ing to give up my French cit­i­zen­ship if I had had to choose…especially that all my fam­ily is in France.

    @kyh — Becom­ing an expat, and then an immi­grant, a new cit­i­zen is a fas­ci­nat­ing expe­ri­ence indeed. But one must like bureau­cracy and paperworks!

    @Brenda — Same here, even though I love Canada, I miss trav­el­ing… can’t always get what you want I guess!

    @RennyBA — US does accept dual cit­i­zen­ship now actu­ally, I though that they didn’t and after some research, I dis­cov­ered it was a myth. It is a bit con­fus­ing though apparently.

    @DianeCA — Diane, you may not have to let go, since from what I read, US does rec­og­nize dual cit­i­zen­ship. You may want to read that: http://www.richw.org/dualcit/

  • Adam says:

    A belated “con­grat­u­la­tions” on your Cana­dian Citizenship!

  • expatraveler says:

    I’m much like you for my sta­tus in Cal­i­for­nia. Most of it is lost, although I do vote. I do have to file taxes but besides that I want to become a Cana­dian Cit­i­zen. I still get called for Jury duty and tell them it’s too hard to go there when I’m per­ma­nently in another country…

    Much the same, but I still long to go back to Europe so that I don’t loose more of my FRENCH!

1 Pingbacks »

What is on your mind? Share it!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also Comments Feed via RSS.

All comments are welcomed!

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get yours, head to Gravatar.