Trends

Debates, discussions, news articles, cultural differences stories and everyday life blah blah.

On The Road

Follow me in China, in Central and in South America, in Australia, in South-East Asia or in Europe. Enjoy the pics and crazy travel stories!

Immigration

How to immigrate to Canada, how to apply for Canadian citizenship, and how to tackle the challenges newcomers face.

Baby Mark Floyd

Mark, our Canadian-Chinese-French baby, was born in Ottawa on October 12, 2012. These are our adventures as parents-in-training.

The Saturday Series

The ten post Saturday series: how to immigrate to Canada, how to find a job, interviews with immigrants… and more!

Home » Immigration

I Want Out… But How and Why?

Written by on March 14, 2011 – 9:53 am18 Comments | 1,456 Read this

This Way!, Bank Street, Ottawa

I often hang out on r/IWantOut, Red­dit’s offi­cial expat sub­red­dit. Peo­ple post infor­ma­tion about immi­gra­tion and ask for feed­back regard­ing a par­tic­u­lar place or coun­try. But this sub­red­dit seems to be dom­i­nated by those (a major­ity of Amer­i­cans) who are sick of their coun­try and want to get out of it. Posts titled “I’d go any­where”, “Can’t take it any­more, look­ing to move out of the U.S.A” are legion.

Like one Red­di­tor put it, “I’m a lit­tle tired of posts that say ‘I’m in high school and I don’t know any lan­guages but the USA SUCKS MAN.’ Can we restrict this to posters who have done some research, know they might have qual­i­fi­ca­tions that could assist in get­ting out and are in process to get­ting out?”

This atti­tude is com­mon when it comes to immi­gra­tion. A lot of peo­ple want to leave their coun­try for polit­i­cal or eco­nomic rea­sons. I get emails through this blog that basi­cally say: “I’m des­per­ate to leave XYZ coun­try, how I can move to Canada eas­ily?” And when I start explain­ing that mov­ing to Canada is usu­ally do-able but that you have to meet a few require­ments, do research etc. their inter­est vanishes.

I com­pletely under­stand peo­ple who are sick of their coun­try. I didn’t par­tic­u­larly enjoy liv­ing in France either and I often thought that being born and raised there wasn’t a good enough rea­son to stay. That said, I think a lot of prospec­tive immi­grants need a reality-check.

First, do you real­ize what immi­grat­ing entails? I per­son­ally think that see­ing and expe­ri­enc­ing the world is a must before set­tling any­where. Get out of your city, of your province, of your coun­try and see what you miss and what you don’t. Some­times it takes a trip abroad to real­ize that you actu­ally enjoy liv­ing in your coun­try, no mat­ter how imper­fect it may be.

Sec­ond, do you have a real­is­tic plan? You want to move. Good. Now, administratively-speaking, can you actu­ally live in your coun­try of choice? Some coun­tries, includ­ing Canada, the U.S.A, Aus­tralia and New Zealand do have offi­cial immi­gra­tion pro­grams. But you still have to be selected, and most of the time you will need to have the skills, work expe­ri­ence and edu­ca­tion that the coun­try is miss­ing. Other places are a bit of a grey area. For instance, if you want to move to China you will have fewer options since the coun­try doesn’t actively seek immi­grants. In fact, it only started draft­ing the country’s first immi­gra­tion law. Mean­while, most for­eign­ers are only allowed to reside here for rea­sons of work, study, travel, or mar­riage over a cer­tain period of time.

Are you will­ing to adapt to another cul­ture? First you will likely have to speak the country’s lan­guage in order to get a job. Even expats in, let’s say, Thai­land have a bet­ter life if they can actu­ally speak Thai. Eng­lish may be the inter­na­tional lan­guage of choice but in many coun­tries it is only spo­ken by the upper-class or at work. Adapt­ing to another cul­ture also means being a “life stu­dent” for a few years. You adop­tive coun­try won’t change for you—you have to change.

Are you will­ing to make com­pro­mises? No coun­try is per­fect. Broadly speak­ing, in devel­oped coun­tries you may face extreme con­sumerism, polit­i­cal extremes, selfishness—I already wrote about the Unpleas­ant Real­i­ties of Amer­i­can Life. In less devel­oped coun­tries, cor­rup­tion, pol­lu­tion, poverty, inef­fi­ciency can be an issue.

Finally, I can’t help think­ing that hat­ing one’s coun­try doesn’t make for a suc­cess­ful immi­gra­tion. It can cer­tainly play a dynamic role but it’s not every­thing. You also have to be curi­ous about the world, eager to adapt to a new cul­ture and open-minded. Don’t leave home resent­ful and bring your anger with you. In most cases, immi­grat­ing doesn’t solve any prob­lem you may have.

Case in point: I think it’s pretty clear to any­one who spent time on this blog that I’m left-wing. I hated Chirac’s gov­ern­ment and I dis­like Sarkozy’s even more. I don’t like Harper’s gov­ern­ment either. Am I going to leave Canada because the Con­ser­v­a­tive are in power? Nope. I’m going to vote and make my voice heard. Hope­fully, next time, we will get a smart gov­ern­ment. Fingers-crossed. I’m not going to run around the world look­ing for the per­fect gov­ern­ment. To my knowl­edge it doesn’t exist, plus I’d rather try to make change happen.

I know a lot of French who moved to Canada and absolutely love to tell every­one around them how much bet­ter Canada is, peo­ple are more effi­cient, smarter, more polite, bet­ter edu­cated blah blah blah. I often feel like say­ing “er… do you know you are still French?” Indeed, not only this kind of atti­tude can get really tir­ing (bitch­ing about France is… so French!) but once abroad you will real­ize how much your birth cit­i­zen­ship is imprinted in you. It’s only in Canada I real­ized that because of my back­ground I was indeed very much European.

Immi­grat­ing is an adven­ture. But I don’t think slam­ming the door on your birth coun­try is the best way to start it. Close it qui­etly instead, and enjoy your new life.

Tagged with:

18 Comments »

  • Em says:

    Well, you’re lucky, because most of the French peo­ple I meet here keep say­ing how much bet­ter France is! I just want them to go back home. I actu­ally appear as a fran­co­phobe, not because I say that every­thing is so much bet­ter than in France (it isn’t and as you say, no coun­try is per­fect), but because I have come to despise the arro­gant atti­tude of most French peo­ple I have met here. Thank­fully, not every­body is like that and there are some sound-out peo­ple from anywhere.

  • Seraphine says:

    here’s what i think:
    some kinds of peo­ple think immi­grat­ing is an adven­ture. they think their lives will be mag­i­cally trans­formed into some­thing excit­ing and bet­ter.
    wouldn’t it be great to leave ill­ness and unpaid bills behind, to leave an unhappy mar­riage or a dead-end job and start over?
    the real­ity is these types of peo­ple prob­a­bly will have the same prob­lems, no mat­ter where they go.

  • Rich B says:

    I won­der every­day if my move to Canada was a good idea. Every­day the answer is “yes”. It’s not rad­i­cally dif­fer­ent from what I’m used to being a upstate New Yorker-but very dif­fer­ent dif­fer­ent at the same time. (I know that doesn’t make sense some­times)
    I’m happy to be where I am, I’m still American-and will always be so-even if/when I get cit­i­zen­ship here. (I am, how­ever, get­ting tired of being the for­eign pol­icy ‘explainer’/ambassador for every move the US of A has made in the last 20 years!).
    I know it’s bet­ter for my kids, my wife and me. I just wish the beer was cheaper! (and not I’m not dri­ving to Que­bec to buy Coors lite at the Cosco peo­ple! I don’t drink that crap! I may be Amer­i­can but I have some taste!)

1 Pingbacks »

What is on your mind? Share it!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also Comments Feed via RSS.

All comments are welcomed!

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get yours, head to Gravatar.